Wills · Estate planning

Choosing an executor: 5 mistakes people make

By Hope Nebbeling · UK guide · Updated August 2026 · ~5 min read

Your executor has one of the hardest jobs in your family: they'll spend 6 to 12 months dealing with banks, HMRC, the Land Registry, and every provider you ever had an account with. Picking the wrong person doesn't just delay things, it can create tension that lasts for years. These are the 5 mistakes we see most often when families come to us to rewrite a Will.

01
Naming just one person, with no backup

The single most common mistake. People name their spouse, or their eldest child, and stop there. Then when the time comes, that person has passed away first, is too unwell to act, or has become estranged. There's no legal executor, so the family has to apply for Letters of Administration under intestacy, wasting weeks.

What to do instead: always name at least one substitute. Structure it as “my spouse, and if they cannot act, then my daughter and son jointly”. That way there's always someone with authority.

02
Naming someone older than you

Choosing your own parent, an aunt, or an older sibling as your executor feels natural, they know your affairs and you trust them. But the odds are you'll outlive them, or they'll be too elderly to handle the demands of the role when the time comes. We see this constantly: an 80-year-old surviving spouse trying to manage a 6-month probate process while also dealing with grief.

What to do instead: lean toward executors who are a similar age or younger, especially for the substitute role. A trusted adult child or younger sibling is often the strongest long-term choice.

03
Naming multiple children but not thinking about how they get on

“All three of my children, together” feels fair. But joint executors have to agree on every decision, and estates unearth strong feelings. We've seen executor disputes over which auction house to use, whether to sell the family home, and how to split personal possessions of no real financial value. Once a dispute starts, the estate can freeze for months.

What to do instead: if you're worried about family dynamics, name one primary executor with the others as substitutes, or name a solicitor as a joint executor so there's a neutral voice. It costs a little more but often prevents years of family fallout.

04
Assuming your spouse will “just handle it”

Most married people name their spouse as sole executor. That's usually fine if your spouse survives you, is well enough to act, and is comfortable with paperwork, HMRC forms and dealing with legal processes while grieving. Many aren't. Many have never seen the family finances in detail. The stress can be substantial.

What to do instead: name your spouse, but also name a substitute (an adult child, a sibling, a friend who's good with admin). Consider whether “together with our daughter” might actually take pressure off rather than add to it.

05
Not asking the person first

Many people name executors without ever mentioning it. The person only finds out when the Will is read after the death. They may not want the responsibility, may live overseas and struggle to act, or may simply not have the time. Legally they can renounce the role, but the family then has to sort out who acts instead, at exactly the worst moment.

What to do instead: have the conversation while you're all well. It's often easier than people fear. Most people are honoured to be asked, and those who can't take it on will say so, saving your family the problem later.

The people you should not name

Frequently asked questions

How many executors should I appoint in my Will?
You can name up to four executors acting at any one time. Two is usually the sweet spot: one main, one backup. Always name at least one substitute in case your first choice is unable to act.
Can a beneficiary be an executor?
Yes, it's very common. A spouse or adult child often inherits the bulk of an estate and acts as executor. There's no legal conflict, though think about whether it might create tension with other beneficiaries.
What does an executor actually have to do?
Register the death, value the estate, apply for probate, deal with HMRC, collect in assets, pay debts, and distribute what's left. Full estate administration typically takes 6 to 12 months. Our probate timeline guide covers this in detail.
Can I change my executor later?
Yes, at any time. Either write a new Will or add a formal amendment (codicil). Worth reviewing every 5 years or after major life events.

Rewriting your Will? Let's talk it through

We meet with you in person to help you make the right executor and guardianship choices, at a fixed fee agreed in writing before we start.

Written by Hope Nebbeling, Client Relationship Manager at GLCS Probate Services Ltd. Regulated by the Council for Licensed Conveyancers (Licence 14742). This guide gives general information for England and Wales only and is not legal advice. For your own situation, please book a free consultation on 01293 804 665.